Wtf?
I had to create a new category called, Wtf?, just because of what happened to us at music class this morning. We’ve been home for over an hour now and my mind keeps reeling back to the music teacher and what she said in class. I can’t stop asking myself, ”Wtf?” Seriously, I need to bounce this of y’all to see if you think I’m overreacting or if you think this lady needs a politically correct smackdown. Here’s the down-low.
Our teacher, Ms. S, just announced the next song we were to sing. I got Miles all extra excited because it was his all time favorite song, Little Baby Monkey. Well, I don’t need to remind you how Miles feels about monkeys and he could hardly contain himself with anticipation. He quickly let out one of his infamous screeches and his right hand shot up in the air and he proceeded to pump it up and down. The only thing we were missing was for him to flick his lighter on.
So, Ms. S proceeds to tell us a little background information on Little Baby Monkey and told us that the song has an African rhythm and that it is played on the piano using only the black keys just like Amazing Grace. I thought to myself, interesting information, Ms. S. She then said, the black keys are also known as the Negro keys or slaves keys and that is when I said, “Oh no she di’n't!”
I think I was in disbelief at what I just heard and my face got all scrunched up, just like it did when Jason told me he bought four tickets to the ACDC concert in December. But I didn’t say anything, and before I knew it I was singing, “Little baby monkey jumping up in a tree.”
I thought about saying something to Ms. S after class but I still was too angered by it. If you knew me in real life, you know, in that state of mind, I would have been all up in her face, head cocked, finger waving, calling her an ignorant, racist biotch. And then everyone would in turn, be calling me, C to the R-A-Z-Y.
So, now I’m debating whether to email Ms. S or to contact the owner of the business directly. Or do any of you think I’m being oversensitive and overracting and should just let it go? I’m concerned that in our next class she’ll tell us that Brazil nuts are also known by another name.
Loading...
I think this is a big deal. Many things, people, places have very hateful, racist names but that doesn’t mean that we say them, share them, teach them. I agree WTF…send an email to both the teach and the owner. Get your money back for that class!!!
Leah - September 24, 2008 at 2:35 pm
Oh no she di’n't!!! You should e-mail her and cc it to the owner. Not cool!
Tiffany - September 24, 2008 at 3:37 pm
Oh crap. I’m sure I know how she meant it because a lot of Jazz and Blues (based off of Negro spirituals) are played in minor chords (using a lot of black keys) but the way she said it was atrocious! She nees a little edumacation, toute suite! Plus, that kind of musical information might just be a little TMI for a pre-Kindermusic kinda vibe. She should have stopped at “African Beat.”
christie - September 24, 2008 at 6:14 pm
I think the Momma Bear in you had every right to attack…Keep us posted!
Karen - September 24, 2008 at 6:48 pm
As soon as I read this my jaw dropped (out of horror) – however, I started googling “Amazing Grace black keys only” and there is actually a lot of information – several use the terms “slave keys” and one even says “slave scale”
Personally, I would have felt the same way you did (maybe she just shouldn’t have mentioned it).
Kate - September 24, 2008 at 7:16 pm
You HAVE to say something. That was not handled right at all…then punch her:-)
jocelyn - September 24, 2008 at 8:57 pm
I agree with the other commenters…it may be a fact that the black keys have been called by those names, but it wasn’t appropriate, or necessary to say that in class. If it were me, I would just approach her before or after the next class and just say “Hey, what you said in the last class about the names for black keys made me uncomfortable. I’m sure you didn’t mean anything by it, but I wanted to just tell you that passing along information like that can make people uncomfortable. Maybe in the future you should limit your explanation to the “African beat” part and end it there. Thanks”
Just my two sense.
Heather
Paul and Heather - September 25, 2008 at 9:28 am
Isn’t that a class for mommies and babies? Why would she be giving you a history lesson. I would say something. I don’t think that it is appropriate for her to bring that up in class. They are babies and they don’t care they just want to hear that song. Good luck and keep us posted! Miles is such a little cutie pie!
Lynn - September 25, 2008 at 9:54 am
I think it was inappropriate to bring it up to a class full of babies who obviously wouldn’t get it. If this was a music appreciation class or history of music class, then it would’ve been ok, even an interesting tidbit. But in front of a bunch of kids, it just seems to odd to bother mentioning it at all.
Diane - September 29, 2008 at 2:48 pm
I love the new category! We could completely add our own “Wtf!” moments to it. Maybe I should create this tag on our blog.
Sweetie you totally did the right thing by taking a breather. As Moe gets older you won’t necessarily have the chance to take “5″ before you speak – so uses this flexibility while you have it. In the future you will need to give immediate mature responses even if you feel like reachin’ out and touchin’ the teacher in a less than friendly way.
Go back and speak to the teacher as everyone has recommended. Big hugs to you and Moe!
Trix - September 30, 2008 at 10:07 pm
I’ll dare to stick my neck out on this one, but the teacher is right about the historic background and how the song came about. However, this may just be a bit too sophisticated for such a young audience.
I’d take it with a grain of salt, but I really do not believe she actually insulted anybody providing this kind of information.
May I suggest a polite conversation next time you meet, letting her know that you do appreciate her knowledge; however, she needs to consider her audience and that some children may not yet be ready to have this kind of talk.
Peace and Gummibears
Mick - October 1, 2008 at 8:41 am